LIBRES: Library and Information Science Research
Electronic Journal ISSN 1058-6768
2001 Volume 11 Issue 2; September 31
Bi-annual LIBRES 11N2
Erotica in Australian Libraries: Are We Negligent
Edgar Crook, Librarian
Literary erotica has existed alongside erotic art and sculpture for as
long as there has been the capacity to publish or otherwise transmit the
written word. In ancient
"..in addition to "the thousand natural shocks" that books are heirs to, this particular kind is subject to other dangers. They do not usually find their way into public libraries, where they would be comparatively secure, but are for the most part possessed by amateurs, at whose death they are not infrequently burned; and they are always liable to destruction at the hands of the law. Their scarcity then, supposing their original issues to be identical, is very much in proportion to their age; and as society is constantly, so to say, at war with them, the natural course is for them to die out altogether."
The very few libraries that do have reasonable collections such as that held in the ‘Private case collection’ of the British Library did not themselves collect them but were the beneficiaries of privately owned formed collections. That private collectors amassed collections of this material and not libraries was often due to the illegality of publishing this type of material. It has only been comparatively recently that erotica producers have been able to market their wares without fear of prosecution, and so are able to send in copies of their publications as legal deposit. The British Library however itself did not initially seek to have this collection at all. One of the greatest donators of erotica to that library was the aforementioned Henry Ashbee. His collection survived only because he wisely put in a proviso in his bequest that the library could have his outstanding collection of Cervantes original editions if they also pledged to house and preserve his collection of extremely rare erotica.
Although in the past, librarians were or were considered rather
tweedy and puritanical, today they are far more likely to be libertarian in
outlook. In the
III. Libraries should challenge censorship in the fulfillment of their responsibility to provide information and enlightenment.
IV. Libraries should cooperate with all persons and groups concerned with resisting abridgment of free expression and free access to ideas.
An example of how the American library world puts these beliefs into practice is the nationally observed Banned Books Week. This event which has been successfully run in public libraries since 1981, and is organised by librarians together with publishers and other media representatives. Its aim is to highlight the attempts made by persons and organisations to censor books, and promotes counter censorship information and empowerment.
“In places to which the public has right of access, save where the flow of information must be restricted by reason of confidentiality, members have an obligation to facilitate the flow of information and ideas and to protect and promote the rights of every individual to have free and equal access to sources of information without discrimination and within the limits of the law”
This is a clear statement of opposition to censorship, but it is unfortunately tempered by a later section which states:
"Members should not knowingly promote material the prime purpose of which is to encourage discrimination on the grounds of race, colour, creed, gender or sexual orientation."
This later section developed by the liberal to disallow the libertarian, can be used as a tool of censorship by a librarian who has the opinion, for example, that sexual matter is in itself discriminatory, or that persons of colour or sexual orientation who appear or don't appear within a works pages are also discriminated against.
Australian librarians remain generally opposed to censorship and the peak body for librarians, the Australian Library and Information Association (ALIA), actively though not publicly fights censorship through its input into government policy making bodies. The guiding principle in matters of collection development and censorship for Australian librarians appears in the ALIA Statement on Freedom to Read:
“A librarian should not exercise censorship in the selection of materials by rejecting on moral, political, racial or religious grounds alone material which is otherwise relevant to the purpose of the library and meets the standards, such as historical importance, intellectual integrity, effectiveness of expression or accuracy of information which are required by the library concerned. Material should not be rejected on the grounds that its content is controversial or likely to offend some sections of the library's community.”
Although laudable, this statement unfortunately is often ignored
when it comes to matters of graphic sexuality. Australian libraries do purchase
literary erotica produced by the major publishers. This is a reflection of the
fact that the market for literary erotica has in the last few years grown
exponentially. With the decline of pulp
paperbacks of little literary merit which were directed at males, there
has been a consequent growth and active marketing push for quality literary
erotica aimed at women. The huge popularity of Australian-produced erotic
fiction such as Tobsha Learner’s Quiver : a book of erotic tales, Linda Jaivin’s Eat Me and Susan
Johnson’s Women Love Sex has created a demand that libraries have
been fulfilling. Today, therefore, literary erotica is almost universally
accepted and collected in most libraries. However, it is still almost
impossible to find any erotic pictorial matter in any public library. Whether
public libraries should be providing access to sexually explicit magazines, and
how it could possibly be policed is of course an issue which needs further
discussion. Considering there is an obvious market for sexually provocative
mass circulation weekly periodicals such as Picture and People,
as evidenced by their sales figures, libraries would be serving some sections
of society by providing access. Balancing this would be the political reality
of having to justify collections to those opposed to this type of material. In
Although public libraries have good reasons for not collecting
erotica, academic and university libraries which have fewer, are also poor
collectors of the erotic. There are a few exceptions however. Flinders
University of South Australia
Library houses the archives of the Eros foundation - a sex industry lobby group.
In the recent past, no libraries collected and so added to the scarcity of these publications. Librarians were apparently unwilling to obtain and preserve legally published erotic material that they considered of no current or future historic, literary, artistic or intellectual value. On all counts this attitude has been proved false. We have moved from Thomas Carlyle's view that history is the study of great men and events to the current concept of social history, which is the study of ordinary people and their lives as they progress through time. The examination of the society and culture of a period today by necessity involves the study of its sexual life. For example, the erotic matter created in the Victorian era has become of great interest to historians. The few remaining sexual diaries and pornographic novels of this era provide many more insights into past lives than the many moral or social novels that are still so widely enjoyed and frequently adapted to television. Aside from its artistic aspects, erotica has not generally been viewed as fulfilling a socially useful function; in fact, it has done so in a very concrete sense. Erotica has had a major if unacknowledged role in the development of our entertainment and electronic media. Photography both still and moving were improved and made commercially viable by the mass market appeal for the means to capture erotic images. The video industry and latterly the Internet have also benefited. Indeed, if not for Internet porn sites we would not have had developed so quickly all the interactive video, video conferencing and streaming media capabilities which we currently enjoy.
The mission of the National Library of Australia is “to ensure that
a comprehensive record of Australian history and creative endeavor, and a
selected record of universal human knowledge is collected and cared for”. To
fulfill this mission comprehensively the National Library has to collect in
every field no matter how seemingly unimportant. Part of the Library’s mission
therefore, though probably not an overwhelmingly popular one politically or
administratively, is to collect in the area of erotica. It may come as a shock
to some that the Library's shelves struggle to fit in such weighty volumes as Big
'n' Bouncy or Bra Busters, but the National Library does hold these
and many other contemporary periodicals. Its collection of
Scattered throughout Australian libraries are small collections of Australian mainstream erotic pictorial periodicals, which date primarily from the latter half of the 20th Century. In the 1940s, there was a freeing up of the ability to purchase openly publications of this sort, apparently for the benefit of WW2 soldiers looking for diversion in the field or in training. Since that time, there has been no lack of Australian produced erotica. Among the popular early titles were Pertinent, Man, and Man Junior, and the later titles Gals and Gags, Maids and Models, Eves from Adam, Mr. and Stag, most of which were published by K. G. Murray. These publications are quite tame by today’s standards – most of them featured in each issue only one or two nude photographs amongst the many clothed ones. The nude photographs were of women in what were termed ‘artistic’ poses and were often airbrushed to hide the female genitalia, so that they resembled classical sculptures.
Since the 1970s, a decade which saw a huge rise in the open
production of erotica, those few collecting libraries have received via legal
deposit into their collections a large number of erotic periodicals and other
sex-related publications. Many of the periodicals are wholly Australian in
origin whilst some are Australian editions of US magazines such as Penthouse,
Hustler and Playboy. There are regional versions of these
periodicals such as the
Since the early 1970s some libraries have also collected gay male erotica. When the production and dissemination of homoerotic images became legal and actual with the publication of titles such as Stallion (1973-4), Naked Teens (1974) and Australian Golden Boys (1973-4), libraries began to form collections of gay pictorial matter featuring photographs of nude men. Although no library has been able to collect exhaustively in this area, the chances of gay erotica not being preserved and therefore lost are mitigated by the efforts of the Australian Lesbian and Gay Archives in Melbourne which has collected over 15,000 items (though not all erotica) since its inception in 1978.
The erotica industry today produces an often hidden but still very substantial amount of all published material. Erotica has become accepted as part of the legitimate publishing world as evidenced by the 300,000 copies of Australian adult sexual publications sold weekly. For Australian libraries not to collect at least a sample of this production will severely diminish the future historical record and distort the true sexual nature of the society we live in. It is important that libraries collect this material. If not for now, then as an indicator of social mores, standards and public attitudes to matters sexual for the future reader, the social scientist, historian or sexologist a hundred or a thousand years hence.
American Library Association, Banned Books
Week, [online] http://www.ala.org/pio/presskits/bbwkit/bbw00release.html
American Library Association, Library Bill
of Rights, [online], http://www.ala.org/work/freedom/lbr.html
Ashbee, Henry, [Pisanus Fraxi], Index librorum
prohibitoru, being notes bio- biblio- icono-graphical and critical, on curious
and uncommon books,
Australian Library and Information
Association, Statement on freedom to read, [online] http://www.alia.org.au/policies/freedom.to.read.html
Byrne, Alex, The story of Yongyi: intellectual freedom and academic libraries, [online] http://www.lib.uts.edu.au/mkts_forum/AB_transcript.html
Eros Foundation, Between the Sheets: sex facts from the suburbs, [online] http://www.eros.com.au/btsheets.php, 2000.
Hyde, H. Montgomery, A history of
Inge , Thomas M. (ed.) Handbook of American
popular culture, 2nd ed.,
Kendrick, Walter M., The secret museum:
pornography in modern culture,
Kinsey Institute for Research in Sex, Gender and Reproduction, History of the Institute, [online] http://www.indiana.edu/~kinsey/abtki.html
Library Association, Code of Conduct,
Marcus, Steven, The other Victorians : a
study of sexuality and pornography in mid-nineteenth-century
National Library of
Sova, Dawn B, Literature suppressed on
Stroebel, L and Zakia, R. (eds.), The Focal
encyclopedia of photography, 3rd ed.,
This document may be circulated freely
with the following statement included in its entirety:
This article was originally published in
LIBRES: Library and Information Science
Electronic Journal (ISSN 1058-6768) September 31, 2001
Volume 11 Issue 2.
For any commercial use, or publication
(including electronic journals), you must obtain
the permission of the author.
Edgar Crook, Librarian
National Library of
To subscribe to LIBRES send e-mail message to
with the text:
subscribe libres [your first name] [your last name]